Going South

RKD STUDIES

10.2 Lievens and Venetian Art in Antwerp


Lievens was in Antwerp from 1635 to 1644. Here too, a number of the very best Venetian paintings could be seen. Unlike in London, the art milieu in Antwerp was not dominated by royalty and aristocrats, but by the wealthy middle class. The Twelve Years’ Truce (1609–1621) brought prosperity which enabled the cultivated bourgeois to buy paintings, thus contributing to the resurgence of the arts in Antwerp in the 17th century. In the 16th century, most collections in Antwerp exclusively consisted of Netherlandish paintings.1 Peter Paul Rubens’ (1577–1640) varied collection was therefore a novelty and served as a catalyst for the change in preference among Antwerp connoisseurs towards ancient and Italian art. Rubens’ ardour for Italian pictures was initially exclusively shared by other artists such as van Dyck2 and when Lievens moved to Antwerp in 1635, the collections of these two revered painters were by far the most extensive source on Italian art.3

Rubens’ collection consisted of a variety of tastes, eras and regions.4 Of his group of Italian paintings, all but two were by 16th-century Venetian masters, 11 of which were paintings and oil sketches by Titian.5 Rubens owned Titian’s marvellous Self-Portrait [11], additionally he also had four portraits by Tintoretto, such as the Young Man from the Renialme Family [12] and three by Veronese, one of which was Livia Colonna with a little dog [13]. This group was supplemented by Rubens’ own copies of Titian [14] and other Venetians.6 Rubens’ collection of paintings was a remarkable store of knowledge and information, from which he drew inspiration for his own work. Rubens is known to have opened his collection to learned men, because he believed that discussing its contents with like-minded people was an integral part of collecting.7 Rubens’ approach to further the art historical debate along with open access makes it hard to imagine that Lievens would not have had the opportunity to view these great works.

11
Tiziano
Self-portrait of Tiziano (c. 1488-1576), c. 1562
Madrid (city, Spain), Museo Nacional del Prado


12
Tintoretto
Portrait of a young man from the Renialme Family
San Francisco, Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco, inv./cat.nr. 52.26

13
Paolo Veronese
Portrait of Livia Colonna
Madrid (city, Spain), Museo Nacional del Prado, inv./cat.nr. P000486


It is well known that Anthony van Dyck found great inspiration in Titian’s work, and his collection, referred to as ‘Cabinet de Titien’, is indicative of this fact.8 Van Dyck had no fewer than 19 original Titians, which he hung in one room together as a remarkable annexe to his studio. Most of these were portraits, followed by four of van Dyck’s copies after Titian, and he also owned works by Tintoretto and Jacopo Palma Vecchio (1480–1528).9 Van Dyck purchased many of these paintings in Italy, brought his collection to Antwerp in 1627 and only shipped his paintings to London late in 1635, several months after Lievens’ arrival in Antwerp.10 Considering that van Dyck and Lievens were well acquainted — with van Dyck’s move to the Southern Netherlands in 1634 likely inspiring Lievens to do the same — the two artists probably engaged socially when they were in the same city.11 Reconstructing the full scope of van Dyck’s collection is particularly difficult since a major part of his cabinet was smuggled from London to Flanders in 1645. As a result, only a handful of paintings can be identified with certainty,12 one of which was the impressive Perseus and Andromeda [15] from Titian’s Poesie series, the famous group of mythological scenes and allegories with strong erotic elements that were groundbreaking in the depiction of the female nude.13

In addition to these two major collections, Antwerp was home to many other ‘konstkabinetten’ of wealthy individuals, who imitated princely collectors, yet these collections are often lacking in documentation and are under-researched. Two such Antwerp merchants were Johannes and Jacob Van Veerle, who traded in both their home town and Venice. Carlo Ridolfi (1594–1658) described their collection in his Le Maraviglie dell’ Arte (1648) and a number of their paintings were etched by Wenzel Hollar (1607–1677).14 Ridolfi also writes of Jacomo de Cachiopin (1578–1642), a scion of an old Spanish family who lived and collected in Venice. He was an important patron of Anthony van Dyck and amassed an impressive collection of old and contemporary Netherlandish artists, comprising six paintings attributed to Titian, eight by Tintoretto and others by Andrea Schiavone (1500/15–1563) and Veronese.15 Rubens and van Dyck were certainly interested in such a collection and are known to have conversed with the owner.16 It is not certain whether Lievens would have seen any of these ‘konstcabinetten’, yet since they were less exclusive than many of the collections in London, it is safe to assume that Lievens would have been granted access if he requested to do so. Around 1650, the dissolution of Charles I’s great collection made Italian painting and ancient sculpture more accessible to the Antwerp market,17 and given the presence of a few exceptional collections and the general culture of debating art amongst collectors, artists, and art lovers alike, Lievens had the opportunity to view Venetian masterworks during his time in Antwerp.

14
Peter Paul Rubens after Tiziano
Portrait of Marchesa Isabella d' Este (1474-1539), c. 1605
Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum, inv./cat.nr. 1534

15
Tiziano
Perseus and Andromeda, 1554-1556
London (England), Wallace Collection, inv./cat.nr. P11


Notes

1 Philips van Valckenisse (1554–1614) was an exception, he amassed a collection with a handful of Italian pictures by 1614: Denucé 1932, p. IX.

2 Only in the second half of the century did amateurs such as Diego Duarte (1612–1691) follow Rubens’ example. Ibid., p. 71.

3 It is unlikely that Lievens ever got to see the monumental collection of Archduke Leopold Wilhelm, since the regent and his paintings only settled in Brussels by 1647, three years after Lievens moved back to the Netherlands. These paintings were published in the first substantial printed catalogue of a collection of paintings that is illustrated with prints, the Theatrum Pictorium (1660), made by David Teniers II. Collectors in Amsterdam such as Jan Six (1618–1700) had copies of this book, so Lievens could have seen the prints after all the Venetian masters. Waterfield et al. 2006, p. 19. Meijer 1999, p. 84.

4 Our principal evidence for what Rubens displayed in his house in Antwerp is the inventory made for his family after his death by Franchois Hercke, in which 314 paintings were itemised. The arts of Egypt, Greece, Rome, the early Netherlands, Germany, the Italian Quattrocento and Cinquecento of the Venetian, Roman, and Lombard schools, and of the Northern and Southern Netherlands, and Italy in Rubens’s day were all represented, in the form of paintings, drawings, prints and sculpture. Jaffé 1969, p. 649.

5 Muller 1989, p. 19.

6 Jaffé 1969, p. 649.

7 Muller 1989, p. 65.

8 Wood 2010, p. 33.

9 Wood 1990, p. 681–682.

10 Ibid., p. 681. Van Dyck did not have his own house in London between 1632 and 1634, during which time he was accommodated by Edward Norgate. Cust 1900, p. 87.

11 DeWitt 2006, p. 146.

12 Apart from Perseus and Andromeda, these are The Vendramin Family, Portrait of Cardinal Antoniotto Pallavacini, as well as a copy by van Dyck of Titian’s Venus Blindfolding Cupid. Wood 1990, p. 686.

13 Among the Poesie are Danae (Museo del Prado, Madrid), Venus and Adonis (Museo del Prado, Madrid), Diana and Actaeon and Diana and Callisto (National Gallery of Scotland), Perseus and Andromeda (Wallace Collection, London), Death of Actaeon (National Gallery, London), Rape of Europa (Isabella Steward Gardner Museum, Boston). Tarquin and Lucretia (Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge) was part of the collection of Charles I. Ferino-Pagden 2008, p. 202. Ilchman 2009, p. 181. Wood 1990, p. 691.

14 Lugt 1936, p. 131; Logan 1979, p. 54. Their collection included Giorgione’s Self-Portrait and Portrait of a Young Man, and Titian’s Portrait of Daniele Barbaro, Patriarch of Aquileia. From Hollar’s prints we can also identify Titian, Bindo Altovitii (P1339), Titian, Pietro Aretino (P1348), Giorgione, Buffelmacco or ‘Todescho di Casa Fuchera’ (P1367), Sebastiano del Piombo, Vittoria Colonna (P1379), Palma Vecchio, Petrarch’s Laura (P1455), Titian, Titian’s Daughter (P1511).

15 Watteeuw 2004, p. 121. Another major art cabinet in Antwerp was that of Cornelis van der Geest (1577–1638), of which our knowledge is largely based on the gallery paintings by Willem van Haecht (1593–1637). These depict mainly paintings by Antwerp masters although a few Italian paintings can be discerned. Denucé 1984, p. VII–VIII.Other important collectors were Peter Stevens (1590–1668), Nicolaas Rockox (1560–1640) and Jan van Borm. Peeter Stevens was a cloth merchant who was well acquainted with Van der Geest. The content of this collection shows that he solely collected Flemish painting and did not care much for the highly praised Italian masters. Briels 1980, p. 164–168.

16 Ibid., p. 119. Glück 1941, p. 194.

17 Muller 1989, p. 71.

Cookies disclaimer

While surfing the internet, your preferences are remembered by cookies. Cookies are small text files placed on a pc, tablet or cell phone each time you open a webpage. Cookies are used to improve your user experience by anonymously monitoring web visits. By browsing this website, you agree to the placement of cookies.
I agree